"It is my plan, following the example of the prophets and ancient fathers of the church, to compose vernacular psalms for the masses; that is spiritual songs, so that the Word of God might also remain in song among the people. To this end we are searching everywhere for poets." -- Martin Luther
(1). When writing for the church write for YOUR church. - Try not to give effort to other musical ambitions or agendas. The non-negotiables in anything you write is that is has biblical integrity, and is inspiring and memorable to sing musically. Ask: What lyrics does my church need to sing? What is a melody they will be able to sing? Forget popular artists or classical musical training. Consider your church. The more you copy the popular thing at the moment, the less original you'll be.
(2). Find an appropriate outlet for your work to explore its potential. - Try out your songs on trust close friends. Try them out in a small group. If it "works" there then it may be fit for larger congregational singing.
(3). Be realistic in your expectations. - The majority or your songs may not be that good. Consider that 95% of the songs you write will not be fit for public singing. So write a lot and use only the very best for congregational singing. The rest might be for personal use, family use, small groups, etc.
(4). Be a student of the art form. - Songwriting is an art form, not theological propaganda. Study art and study beauty. Study melodies that work well for a congregation. Ask why the work. Dissect them and consider the techniques and forms. Remember that you can't pull water out of a dry well. Be drinking continually from the Word of God. Remember that a good lyric will be lost if the melody is unsingable.
(5). Crave fresh language and sound. - There is always more to write. There are always fresh way to say old truths. Consider than 90% of worship songs only cover about 10% of the themes in the Psalms. We need to push current boundaries in songwriting. If you pursue the current sound and content of culture, you'll be certain to write songs that don't last.
Begin with the seed of an idea for a song. Expand that seed to grow into a trunk which will grow into branches. What's the big idea (seed)? Communion? Creation? Redemption?
What is the flow of thought in the song (trunk & branches)? How does each verse expand upon the big idea?
Then composes the leaves (language/poetry/first lines)?
We are trying to inspire response through revelation. That is to say, God's Word should drive us to respond to God properly..
(7). Work collaboratively.
(8). Editing if your friend. - Go over each line again and again. Cut things out. Add things. Change structural things around. Try different timings.
(9). Lean into your unique creative DNA and background. - God made you to be you, not someone else. While you might learn from others and have different experiences that have helped to shape you, you are unique. You have natural tastes and creative abilities. Be yourself as you write.
(10). Four questions to ask for arranging songs for congregations to sing:
(a). What sets up the song for congregation to sing best?(b). What is the essence of the song and how can I make this arrangement allow the music to express that?(c). How can I write to the strengths of my players?(d). Is there a context linked to the song, service or musicians that would allow something fresh?