HISTORICAL BACKGROUND – Jesus said he came to fulfill the Law and the Prophets. Did this mean He was coming to provide an updated version of Judaism in which Old Testament laws were now to be applied to converted non-Jews? In the life of the early church, certain Jewish believers wanted the Gentiles converts to be circumcised and to follow Jewish customs if they were to be saved and counted among God's people. These early Jewish Christians came to be known as the Judaizers.
HERETICAL TEACHING - The Judaizers show up in three major scenes.
- Acts 11:1-19 - Judaizers criticize Peter for eating with non-Jews but he explains the vision he had from God in Acts 10. God revealed to him that Gentiles are to be included in God's kingdom through the abolishing of the Old Testament Jewish dietary laws. Immediately after this vision, Peter is led by the Holy Spirit to the house of a Gentile who believes in Christ as Savior along with other Gentiles. The next step was for them to be baptized, not circumcised.
- Acts 15:1-35 - The first church council discussed what the Judaizers were promoting--namely, that circumcision was required for Gentiles to be saved. Previously, Paul and Barnabas had strongly debated the Judaizers and now the matter was brought before the apostles and elders in Jerusalem. The Judaizers were believers from inside the church but were also Pharisees. The heresy of the Judaizers was shot down by the church council.
- Galatians 2:11-21 - Paul rebuked Peter for not acting in agreement with the gospel. Peter was eating with the circumcision party and has separated himself form Gentiles. The Judaizers were not eating with Gentiles because they believed that made them unclean. This was contrary to the gospel and the vision that Peter had previously received. Paul rhetorically asked Peter how he could demand that the Gentiles live Jews when Peter, a Jew, had been living like a Gentile. The issue with Peter's association with the Judaizers was not that he was following native customs, but that his association with them, and not the Gentiles, was showing the Gentiles that they needed to keep Jews laws to be reconciled with God. The message he was sending was, "You are unclean and therefore unsaved because you don't follow Jewish laws. I don't want to be contaminated, so I'll keep my distance." That is how Paul saw Peter's behavior.
ORTHODOX RESPONSE - God himself discarded the old categories of Jew and non-Jew. This was evidenced by the indwelling Holy Spirit imparted to both Jew and Gentile (Acts 10). Peter knew this to be true since he stated that God granted to Gentiles the same repentance that leads to life (Acts 11:17-18). Paul says the same thing regarding the Holy Spirit but adds that God purified the heart of the Gentiles by faith (Acts 15:8-9). In Colossians 2:17, Paul explains how the things that the Jews loved about the Law were but mere shadows of the reality of Christ.
- In Romans 2:29 Paul explains that the reality of circumcision was never about the cutting off of flesh in order to be considered a Jew (God's people). Rather it was about circumcision of the heart (cutting off of the spiritual flesh or sin nature). Thus, God's covenant people, redefined by Paul, are those who have been spiritually transformed by God whether they be ethnically Jewish or not.
- In Hebrews 4:8-10 we find that the Sabbath laws of the Old Testament were shadows of Christ, our true Sabbath.
- Christ is our guilt offering in which our sins are forgiven (Hebrews 9:13-14).
The New Testament encourages us to cling to Christ, not shadows or pictures of Christ. That is why Paul says that if any requires circumcision for justification and salvation then Christ is of no value (Galatians 5:2-4) and that person has fallen away from grace and is alienated from Christ. Paul is so enraged by this heresy that he wished that the Judaizers would full commit to their cutting off of the flesh and emasculate themselves (Galatians 5:12). Thus, the Jerusalem council did not require circumcision for Gentiles, but only encouraged them to refrain from pagan practices.
Paul's response to the Judaizers was two-fold:
- God saves people freely by grace through faith (Ephesians 2:8-9, 2 Timothy 1:9, Titus 3:4-5).
- The gospel includes both Jewish and Gentile believers (Romans 3:29-30, Romans 4:16, Galatians 3:27-29, Ephesians 2:11-14).
CONTEMPORARY RELEVANCE - The heresy of the Judaizers forced Paul to explain the gospel more precisely. Obedience to God's Law does not save us, for the Law shows us our failures. Rather, obedience to the Law flows from the reality that God has saved us by grace and that he has made us new creatures. We are saved by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone. That is the central issue Martin Luther had with the Catholic Church of his day. His strongest attacks against their heresy of penance and indulgences took place between 1517-1521 after which he began to focus on building up the true church.
While the Judaizers' heresy was a first century problem, the notion of adding obedience, works or law in order to be saved has never died. At the heart of all religions, exception Christianity, works are required. What God has done is more important that what we do. If we aim to be justified before God by law-keeping, then we nullify grace (Galatians 2:21). By definition, grace is unearned.
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
1. How does any form of Judaizing render the work of Christ ineffective?
2. In what ways can Christians act like Judaizers?
3. Do you have a particular rule that you think earns God's favor on your life or others?
4. What group of people do you think should never be included in God's people?
5. Where in your life have you put on a yoke of slavery instead of finding freedom in God's loving and saving grace?
6. If you're familiar with other religions, share how they are not grace-based but law-based.
7. Does our church practice any kind of Judaizing anywhere? If so, what can we do to rectify that?






